Editorial standards

Evidence before certainty

We distinguish verified facts, third-party estimates, hypotheses, and the author's analysis. A number is not treated as proof merely because it is precise.

• Primary documents and first-party datasets take priority.
• Every chart names its source, period, unit, and relevant limitation.
• When evidence is incomplete, the conclusion becomes narrower — not louder.

Sources and anonymity

Named, on-record sources are preferred. An unnamed source may be used when the information is important, the source faces a credible risk, and the claim can be corroborated or its uncertainty made explicit.

Data and methodology

Stories based on marketplace or proprietary data explain the sample, time window, metric definition, transformations, and blind spots. Data obtained through Redstat, 10b.kz, MPStats, or another commercial service is labeled as such.

Ownership and conflicts

Kasymzhanov is owned and edited by Almas Kasymzhanov, who also founded 10b.kz, Redstat, and Brock UI. A material commercial, personal, or data-provider relationship relevant to a story is disclosed in that story.

Use of AI

AI may assist with illustration, transcription, translation, code, and exploratory research. It is not treated as a source. Claims, quotations, calculations, and final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the author. AI-generated or AI-assisted visuals are credited.

Corrections and updates

Substantive corrections are added to the story with a clear note and update date. Quiet fixes are limited to spelling, typography, and formatting that do not change meaning. Readers can report an error by email.